Dealing with the Aftermath of the Amanda Knox Trial: Can She Bounce Back?
A look at why we became a nation fascinated with the trial of the 24-year-old American exchange student. Plus now that she’s free, what kind of life awaits Amanda Knox?
TUESDAY, Oct. 4 — After four years of trials, appeals, and jail time, American student Amanda Knox is finally free. As she collapsed into tears and sobs after the judge overturned her murder conviction, it’s clear that the 24-year-old student has a long road of recovery ahead of her.
Knox, 24, has always been adamant about her innocence in the murder of her former study abroad roommate, Meredith Kercher. Earlier on Monday, Knox, visibly shaking and barely able to stand, made a final plea before the court. “I did not kill. I did not rape. I did not steal. I was not there,” she said. In 2009, Knox and her co-defendant Raffaele Sollecito were convicted for the 2007 murder of Kercher, Knox’s roommate in Perugia, Italy. Knox was sentenced to 26 years in prison; Sollecito was sentenced to 25 years.
However, on Monday, the Italian judge declared the pair not guilty of murder. “We’re thankful that Amanda’s nightmare is over. She suffered for four years for a crime she did not commit,” Knox’s sister, Deanna Knox, said at the courthouse following the verdict.
Why We Care So Deeply About the Knox Trial Outcome
In the wake of the verdict, many took to Twitter and the Web to comment on the case and share in the family’s joy. The public’s infatuation with the high-profile case is reminiscent of that other young brunette on trial for murder earlier this summer (Read: Casey Anthony); however the reactions are completely different.
Whereas Anthony’s acquittal elicited harsh responses from those following the case (one follower Tweeted, “This is a sick and disappointing ending to the Casey Anthony trial.”), the majority of the Knox trial reactions describe a sense of justice winning out. Everyday Health Facebook fan Frances Sanchez said, “Amanda always stuck to her innocence…I think justice prevailed.”
Everyday Health Twitter follower @Beachlady58 said, “I am praying sooo very hard for her freedom. I feel she has been done so wrong by the Italian government.” Another follower, @yella_xo, says, “I think Amanda Knox deserves to be free! I’m happy her conviction was overturned and hope her life can resume to normal.”
Given the high-profile nature of the Knox case plus the mere drama of it all (it has inspired a Lifetime movie and numerous books), it’s no surprise that whether you followed the case from the beginning or not, you have an emotional reaction to the verdict.
“This is a young woman thousands of miles away from home, and she’s being accused of something that they didn’t have enough evidence for,” explains Leslie Seppinni, PsyD, a clinical psychologist in Los Angeles and regular contributor to Nancy Grace on CNN. “She’s a very clean-looking girl. She doesn’t look like a drug or alcohol addict, and because she looks like that people take more interest in whether or not could she have done it.”
Can Knox Ever Resume a Normal Life?
While Knox and her faithful supporters are clearly breathing sighs of relief and screams of joy, the overturned sentence is a bittersweet one. Knox has finally been freed, but she has spent four years of her young adulthood trying to clear her name. And years in prison can take a significant toll on her emotional and physical health.
“Probably at first she’s going to be relieved to come home and to sleep in her own bed. And it’s going to take a minute to realize that this wasn’t a dream,” says Seppinni.
Once reality does set in, the key to a smooth transition and dealing with the reality will be support. “She’s going to need a lot of community support, and hopefully she still has her friendships in place,” says Seppinni. “She’s going to need family support. She’ll also need counseling and maybe even family counseling so that they can be informed of what her experience was like.”
“It will take time to get back to normal,” Ann Rosen Spector, PhD, a professor of psychology at Rutgers University, told ABC News. “She still has had a horrific experience and her sense of trust in police and people is gone. Some people may believe she did it and will treat her differently.”
Even though the American public largely supports Knox, the aftermath of the experience will still be traumatic for her. “She is going to be just as wrecked as Casey Anthony — the trial and the lurid details — the accused sex play and throat slashing and a drug-filled orgy,” Judy Kuriansky, PhD, an adjunct professor of clinical psychology at Columbia University’s Teachers College, told ABC News. “This will continue to follow her forever.”
She’s also still likely coping with the death of her roommate. “As a young person to have someone die in such a horrendous way, she can finally have the opportunity to grieve for that loss,” Seppinni explains.
However Knox chooses to cope with the events of the last four years, the future is up to her. Seppinni summarizes that Knox is at a sort of crossroads with her life right now: Either she can consider herself a victim for the rest of her life, or she can choose to lead a life where she is fulfilled by her passions and dreams.
“I believe you make that choice,” Seppinni says. “So she has some choices to make.”